“As a musician I tell you that if you were to suppress adultery, fanaticism, crime, evil, the supernatural, there would no longer be the means for writing one note.”
– Georges Bizet, French, musician, composer, opera
Although Carmen was not a big success when first presented and performed, it went on to be astonishingly one of top Operas of all time.
Carmen’s extraordinary status transcended the opera house.
Chaplin’s Burlesque on Carmen
Geraldine Farrar in the de Mille movieThe sheer number and variety of forms in which it has appeared and constantly re-emerges is truly astounding and unprecedented for an opera. There were at least seven silent film versions, ranging from sexpots Theda Bara and Pola Negri playing up the sensual side of the character (which became acceptable under the guise of high culture) to Charlie Chaplin‘s 1916 “Burlesque on Carmen,” in which he played Darn Hosiery and used Carmen as one of many slapstick props. Most bizarre of all, a 1915 Cecil B. De Mille production featured Geraldine Farrar, an opera star known for her portrayal of Carmen, but in which her all-important voice couldn’t even be heard!
The rest of the 20th century saw such divergent adaptations as Carmen Jones, in which the story was transposed to black culture, and a flamenco fantasy created by Carlos Saura. Perhaps most outré (so far, that is) – and remarkably effective – is a 2001 Hip Hopera … with a stunning Beyoncé Knowles as a club singer who seduces and corrupts a cop, pries him away from his fiancée and then falls for a conceited rap star. Only time will tell the further variations we surely will see in this seemingly inexhaustible springboard for inspired creativity. ( source )
And for your listening enjoyment a performance of Bizet’s “Carmen, Suite No. 2”. I bet you know quite a few of the melodies – have a listen!
Is music worth all the misery? I guess each person has to answer that for her/himself. Maybe music would just be different. Happy sounds and celebration instead of death marches.
LikeLike
I know most opera deals with the most negative aspects of humanity, treachery, death, betrayal, abandonment and so forth. So in order to do opera, which any self-respecting composer HAD to at least try in the era before and during Bizet’s lifetime, Bizet had to include this type of theme in his work. He laments, in a way, between the lines, that this is the stuff that operas are made of and nothing else would be acceptable to the opera goers of his day! 🙂 Thanks for visiting and commenting! – Douglas
LikeLike
Reblogged this on B.E.S.T. Arts Gallery.
LikeLike
Nice post – Really well written, worth the read!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you liked this! I love sharing stories of how artists were left mostly ignored or unknown, proven to be major innovators as history unfolds. Amazing how so many great artists are simply to far ahead of the people of their time. Yet those held in the highest esteem of their contemporaries are then forgotten by subsequent generations!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree!!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Moorezart.
LikeLike